5 myths about the Middle Ages people still believe

Medieval writing
© History Skills

The Middle Ages, a period spanning roughly from the 5th to the 15th century, is often portrayed in popular culture as a time of darkness, ignorance, and brutality.

 

However, this characterization is based on several myths that have been perpetuated over time.

 

In this article, we will debunk the five biggest myths about the Middle Ages that people still believe.

Myth #1: The Middle Ages were a time of stagnation and backwardness

One of the most persistent myths about the Middle Ages is that it was a time of intellectual and cultural stagnation.

 

This view was first popularized during the Renaissance, which saw itself as a rebirth of classical learning after centuries of neglect.

 

However, recent scholarship has shown that the Middle Ages were a period of tremendous intellectual and cultural activity.

 

This period saw the rise of universities, the development of vernacular literature, and the construction of some of the most impressive works of architecture and engineering in human history.

One particularly noteworthy example is the construction of the Gothic cathedrals, which represent some of the most impressive feats of engineering and architecture in human history.

 

The Gothic cathedrals were built during the High Middle Ages, roughly between the 12th and 14th centuries.

 

These cathedrals are characterized by their soaring arches, ribbed vaults, and pointed arches, which gave them a sense of verticality and lightness that was previously unseen in Western architecture.

 

Some of the most famous examples of Gothic cathedrals include Notre-Dame de Paris, Chartres Cathedral, and Westminster Abbey.

In addition to their impressive architectural features, the Gothic cathedrals were also adorned with stunning works of art, including stained glass windows, sculptures, and frescoes.

 

These artworks were often designed to tell stories from the Bible or to honor saints and other religious figures.

 

Overall, the construction of the Gothic cathedrals represents a remarkable achievement of human creativity and ingenuity, and their legacy continues to inspire and awe people to this day.


Myth #2: The Middle Ages were a time of constant warfare

Another common myth about the Middle Ages is that it was a time of unending warfare and violence.

 

While it is true that this period saw its fair share of conflicts, it is important to note that there were also long periods of relative peace.

 

Moreover, many of the battles that were fought during the Middle Ages were motivated by religious or political ideologies, rather than simple aggression or bloodlust.

In particular, the 'Peace of God' movement was a medieval movement that sought to reduce violence and warfare in Europe during the 10th and 11th centuries.

 

The movement emerged in response to the widespread violence and instability that characterized this period, and it aimed to establish a code of conduct that would protect the lives and property of non-combatants, such as peasants, clergy, and merchants.

 

The Peace of God movement was promoted by the Catholic Church, and it was based on the belief that violence was a sin that would lead to eternal damnation.

 

The movement was also supported by local lords and rulers, who recognized that reducing violence would help to promote stability and economic growth in their territories.

There were several key ways that the Peace of God movement tried to minimize warfare:

  1. Protection of non-combatants: The movement sought to protect non-combatants, such as peasants, clergy, and merchants, from violence and plunder. This was done through the imposition of ecclesiastical sanctions on those who violated the Peace of God, as well as the establishment of safe havens, or "peace towns," where non-combatants could seek refuge during times of conflict.
  2. Limitation of warfare: The movement sought to limit the scope and intensity of warfare by imposing restrictions on the conduct of soldiers and warriors. This included prohibitions on the use of certain weapons, such as bows and arrows, and restrictions on the destruction of crops and livestock.
  3. Promotion of negotiation and reconciliation: The movement emphasized the importance of negotiation and reconciliation in resolving conflicts. This was done through the establishment of courts and councils, where disputes could be heard and resolved in a peaceful manner.

Myth #3: Everyone in the Middle Ages was poor and lived in squalor

The Middle Ages are often depicted as a time of grinding poverty and squalor, with the vast majority of the population living in wretched conditions.

 

While it is true that life was difficult for many people during this period, it is important to note that there were also many who lived comfortable lives.

 

Moreover, the Middle Ages saw the rise of a middle class, with merchants and tradespeople enjoying newfound prosperity and social mobility.

Contrary to popular belief, life in the Middle Ages was not solely focused on work and hardship.

 

People during this period also enjoyed a wide range of entertainment and leisure activities. Here are some examples:

 

Festivals and fairs were popular events that brought people together for music, dancing, food, and games.

 

These events were often tied to religious holidays, but also celebrated agricultural milestones and other important events.

 

Music was an important part of daily life in the Middle Ages, and people enjoyed singing and playing instruments such as the lute, harp, and recorder.

 

Dancing was also popular, with both social dances and more formal dances, such as courtly dances, being enjoyed by all classes of people.

Medieval boardgames
© History Skills

Sports and games were popular leisure activities during the Middle Ages, with activities such as archery, jousting, and hunting being enjoyed by nobles and commoners alike. Board games such as chess and backgammon were also played.

 

Theater and performance were also popular forms of entertainment during the Middle Ages.

 

Mystery plays, morality plays, and other types of drama were performed in churches and other public spaces, while traveling performers such as minstrels and troubadours entertained audiences with their songs and stories.

The Middle Ages were also a time of great artistic and literary achievement, with works such as illuminated manuscripts, tapestries, and stained-glass windows showcasing the creativity and skill of medieval artists.

 

Literature also flourished during this period, with works such as Beowulf, The Song of Roland, and The Canterbury Tales providing a rich and colorful glimpse into medieval life.


Myth #4: The Middle Ages were a time of rampant superstition and ignorance

Another common misconception about the Middle Ages is that it was a time of widespread superstition and ignorance.

 

While it is true that many people during this period believed in supernatural phenomena and practiced folk magic, it is important to note that there were also many who were interested in the natural world and pursued scientific inquiry.

 

In addition, the Middle Ages saw the preservation and transmission of much of the knowledge of the classical world, which would go on to form the basis of modern science.

The people in the Medieval period were deeply fascinated in learning new information, particularly that which obtained through their vast trade networks.

 

Rather than being afraid of knowledge, they quickly incorporated technological advancements into their society.

 

For example, the compass was invented in China during the Han dynasty, but it was not until the Middle Ages that it was adopted in Europe, where it revolutionized navigation and exploration.

 

Sailors were able to determine their direction more accurately, enabling them to chart new courses and discover new lands.

 

While the use of gunpowder for military purposes was a later development, the invention of gunpowder itself is attributed to Chinese alchemists during the Tang dynasty.

 

Gunpowder was later introduced to Europe during the Middle Ages, where it was used for fireworks, mining, and other non-military purposes.


Myth #5: Women had no power in the Middle Ages

Finally, it is often assumed that women had no role in the Middle Ages and were relegated to a life of subservience and silence.

 

While it is true that women faced many limitations during this period, it is important to note that they were also active participants in many areas of life.

 

Women played a vital role in the economy, working as merchants, tradespeople, and artisans.

 

Moreover, there were also women who wielded political power, such as Eleanor of Aquitaine and Isabella of Castile.

The role of women in the Middle Ages varied depending on social status, geographic location, and cultural traditions.

 

While women's rights and opportunities were often limited by the patriarchal social structures of the time, there were also many influential roles that women held during this period.

 

Women played important roles in religious life during the Middle Ages, with many women becoming nuns, abbesses, and mystics.

 

These women were often highly educated and influential within their communities, and their religious writings and teachings had a significant impact on the spiritual and intellectual life of the time.

While women were not typically allowed to join male-dominated guilds, there were many women who worked as merchants and tradeswomen during the Middle Ages.

 

These women often operated small businesses and shops and were responsible for managing finances and negotiating contracts.

 

While opportunities for women in the arts were limited by the prevailing social norms of the time, there were still many women who pursued careers as writers, poets, and artists.

 

Some notable examples include Hildegard von Bingen, a composer, author, and philosopher, and Christine de Pizan, a poet and author who wrote extensively on women's rights and gender equality.