Why did the Roman Empire fall?

Fall of the Rooman Empire
© History Skills

For around 1000 years, from its mythical foundation in 753 BC, until the capture of the city of Rome by Germanic tribes in AD 476, ancient Rome had dominated Europe.

 

After being so powerful for so long, why did Rome eventually fall? There are many theories out there as to why it fell, but no single, definitive answer.

 

In this article, we will explore some of the popular theories surrounding its collapse. We will also take a look at the life of Diocletian – the man who is often credited with almost saving the empire – and discuss Odoacer's role in its fall.

 

Finally, we will explore the reign of Romulus Augustus and how the German tribes played a part in the empire's downfall.

An overview of Rome in the first centuries AD

With the transition of ancient Rome from a Republic to an Empire in the late 1st century BC, Rome experienced significant political, economic, military, and cultural changes.

 

The Roman Empire was vast, stretching from Britain in the west to Mesopotamia in the east.

 

The military presence of the Roman legions throughout the empire created a generally peaceful environment for the empire's citizens.

 

This Roman peace was known in Latin as the Pax Romana. It brought relative peace and stability to the empire, allowing for economic growth, territorial expansion, and the construction of monumental public works.

 

During the 2nd century AD, the Roman Empire was at its height of power and prosperity.

 

Emperors such as Trajan, Hadrian, and Marcus Aurelius ruled and expanded the empire's borders, while the construction of huge building projects and development of law continued.

Streets of an ancient Roman town
© History Skills

However, by the 3rd century AD, problems began to arise. Reduced military expansion meant less economic growth, which led to significant internal turmoil, and an increase in external military threats.

 

In the city of Rome itself, internal power struggles and political instability, made worse by the constant threat of invasions by Germanic tribes, challenged the empire's stability and set the stage for future decline.

 

During the 4th century AD, civil wars between competing Roman emperors devastated the empire.

 

Some leaders, like Diocletian tried various strategies to prevent the ultimate collapse of Rome, with limited effect.

 

Then, by the 5th century AD, the widespread Germanic invasions could not be stopped by the remaining Roman forces and the western half of the empire finally ceased to exist in AD 476.

 

It was in this year that the Germanic king, Odoacer, marched into the city of Rome and removed the final emperor, Romulus Augustus, from power.


Cause 1: The role of the emperors

A popular theory is that the empire was run poorly by successive emperors who were more interested in personal gain than ruling wisely and efficiently.

 

However, some emperors, like Diocletian, tried to save the empire from collapse.

 

Diocletian was born in AD 245 near Salona, in modern-day Croatia. He came from a humble background and worked his way up through the ranks of the military before becoming emperor in AD 284.

 

Once in power, he was proactive in implementing solutions to the ongoing challenges facing the empire. These solutions were known as 'reforms'.

 

Diocletian's reforms helped save the Roman Empire from an earlier collapse by addressing several major issues facing the empire in the late 3rd century AD.

These reforms included:

  1. Administrative Reforms: Diocletian divided the empire into smaller administrative units and appointed a co-emperor (known as an 'Augustus') and deputy emperor (known as a Caesar) to share the burden of rule and increase efficiency.
  2. Military Reforms: Diocletian reformed the army, increasing its size and efficiency, and reorganized the defense along the frontiers to better protect against invasions.
  3. Economic Reforms: Diocletian introduced measures to regulate prices and stabilize the currency, which helped to curb inflation and revive the economy.
  4. Governmental Reforms: Diocletian also created an efficient bureaucratic system that allowed for better communication between officials throughout the empire, making sure things ran smoothly on all fronts.

He retired in AD 305 because he felt it was time to pass on his responsibilities.

 

Today there is still much debate over whether or not Diocletian actually saved the empire from collapse, but what we do know for sure is that he ruled wisely and efficiently during his reign as emperor.

Emperor Diocletian giving a speech
© History Skills

Cause 2: Economics

Economics is the study of money and how it is used. In Rome, the entire empire depended on the constant flow of income from its military conquests.

 

As its armies achieved less victories on the battlefield, less money came into the empire. As a result, a number of economic pressures developed.

 

One of the main economic causes was inflation. The debasement of the currency, combined with government overspending and a declining tax base, led to high inflation and economic instability.

 

This made it difficult for the government to finance its activities and maintain its military, which was critical to the defense of the empire.

 

Agricultural decline was another key factor that contributed to the collapse of the Western Roman Empire.

 

The empire's agricultural productivity decreased, resulting in food shortages, famine, and poverty.

 

This put a strain on the population and made it difficult for the government to secure the food supplies it needed to feed its soldiers and support its cities.

Trade decline was another factor that contributed to the empire's economic difficulties.

 

The disruption of trade networks, the loss of territories, and the decline in the production of goods, caused a reduction in the flow of goods and a decrease in economic activity.

 

This made it difficult for the government to raise revenue through trade and made it more challenging for the population to access goods and services.

 

Taxation was another key factor that contributed to the collapse of the Western Roman Empire.

 

As the rich land-owner aristocracy increasing taxes to try and make more money, the common people became angry.

 

This led to the people rising up in riots and a refusal to pay any taxes at all. As a result, it led to a rapid decline in tax income.

 

Finally, government spending was another factor that contributed to the collapse of the Western Roman Empire.

 

The government's massive spending on military campaigns, public works, and personal luxuries drained the economy and created a large public debt.

 

This made it difficult for the government to finance its activities, and contributed to its eventual downfall as the empire was unable to defend itself against invading barbarian tribes and the rise of local power centers.


Cause 3: The enormous size of the empire

One of the most popular theories surrounding the fall of the Western Roman Empire is that it was simply too big to survive.

 

With an area that extended from Britain in the north, Spain in the west, North Africa in the south, and the fertile crescent in the east, it was difficult to maintain control over such a large territory. 

 

The sheer size of the empire also made it difficult to defend its borders, which left it vulnerable to attack from neighboring countries.

 

Diocletian attempted to solve this problem by dividing the empire into two parts, each ruled by a co-emperor.

 

Diocletian himself took control of the east while Maximian was given control of the west (hence why it's called "the fall of the Western Roman Empire").

 

The division did not last long however, and in AD 310 Constantine I reunited them under his rule as sole emperor.

 

Constantine I then moved the capital from Rome to Constantinople, which was closer to his new territories in Asia Minor and more easily defensible against invaders coming down through Europe.

Roman empire in AD 117
Source: File:Roman Empire Trajan 117AD.png - Wikimedia Commons. Used under Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Roman_Empire_Trajan_117AD.png

Cause 4: Germanic invasions

The Germanic tribes also played a role in the decline of the empire. Various tribes from the region of modern Germany had crossed the empire's northern borders into Roman territories.

 

They were seeking land and resources, which put a strain on the empire's resources.

 

However, after being rejected by the Romans, the Germanic tribes instead wanted to attack towns and take as much as they could. This led to conflict and instability within the empire.

 

At the Battle of Adrianople (which took place near modern Edirne) in AD 378, the emperor Valens was killed along with 20,000 Roman soldiers who were defending against the invaders.

 

This battle marked a turning point for the empire; it showed that Rome could no longer defend itself against these barbarian tribes.

Google Maps content is not displayed due to your current cookie settings. Click on the cookie policy (functional) to agree to the Google Maps cookie policy and view the content. You can find out more about this in the Google Maps privacy policy.

In AD 410, the Visigoths, who were a Germanic tribe, sacked Rome – an event which shocked the Roman citizens and showed them that their empire was not invincible after all.

 

The barbarian leader Odoacer is another important figure in the fall of the Western Roman Empire.

 

He was a Germanic military leader who led his troops into Italy in order to overthrow Romulus Augustus, the last emperor of the Western Roman Empire.

 

Odoacer then ruled Italy as its first king, rather than as emperor, from AD 476 until his death in AD 493.


The Eastern Roman Empire

The Eastern Roman Empire would survive for another 1000 years after the fall of the western half of the Roman Empire.

 

A new capital was founded at Byzantium, and so the eastern empire became known as the Byzantine Empire.

 

The capital would quickly be renamed Constantinople and would survive until the middle of the 15th century. 

Conclusion

In conclusion, the fall of the Western Roman Empire was a complex process that involved many factors such as economic decline, military invasions by barbarians from outside its borders, and political instability.

 

Ultimately, it was a gradual process that culminated in the year AD 476 when Romulus Augustus was deposed by Odoacer.

 

This date has therefore become the traditional date for the end of the Roman Empire in the west.

Roman Forum
Source: https://pixabay.com/photos/forum-romanum-rome-ancient-italy-4583598/

Further reading